We’re bringing a bottle of tequila to the next marketing experts meetup. Read The Goldpanifesto

Unbiased stories & studies from the frontiers of marketing

“How Expensive Are My Ads?”

ezoic ad revenue index (0 – 100)

I’m disagreeing with my copywriter
May 17, 2022

Dear FAM,

I recently hired a copywriter who wrote a new version of our sales page, and I have to say, I really don’t like it. It’s not the kind of tone that I’m used to and I feel it’s too off-brand. Should I go back to my writer for a redo or trust they know what they’re doing?


Writing Worried

Dear Writing Worried,

A few years back, I was on a call with a few friends who ran their own businesses. It was a mastermind call where we were asking questions, getting feedback on new ideas, and so on.

About halfway through the call, one of the guys (let’s call him Jerry) in the group brought up something that happened to him recently. Jerry said he hired a new copywriter to help with sales content on his website. After building a new sales page for an upcoming launch, Jerry read through the copy that this new team member put together—and he hated it.

But, knowing better than to outright deny it (Jerry has a slick scientific brain), he decided to test it. So Jerry wrote his own copy for the launch sales page and launched a split test to find out which version generated higher sales. Lo and behold, the new copywriter’s version blew Jerry’s version out of the water.

The lesson here is to never assume your copywriting skills are better than a professional copywriter. Even if the style, format, or brand they use may be different from what you’re used to, you hired them for a reason. Let them do their job.

A good copywriter will do a ton of research on the audience they’re writing for. They’ll dig through forums, filter through Twitter, and even conduct interviews with customers all in an effort to assume the right “voice” for their writing.

Copywriters are the chameleons of the marketing world. Let them do their thing—you’ll be glad you did. And if you ever have doubts about their skills (which should be driven entirely by the results their writings generate, not your opinions), test it against another version written by you or another copywriter. The results will speak for themselves, as they did for Jerry.

Wait a second... Are you subscribed?

If not, what are you waiting for?!? Subscribing lets me know you actually kind of sort of really like this stuff, which makes me happy to get up in the morning and keep researching curious and interesting marketing stuff. So if you like-a what you see-a, plop your email address below and let’s keep a good thing going.

have we met before?

Well, I’ll be a prospector’s derriere. Are you new here? If so…

Welcome to Goldpan!

This site contains unique stories, compelling theories, sound research, and other curious and interesting posts that will get your creative juices flowing for your next big campaign. 

I host ad hoc mastermind calls, collect feedback for future posts, and start private discussions through my newsletter. It all starts there, right in your inbox, every week.

Want in? Just subscribe below. See you inside.

Dan Russell

Editor—Goldpan Report